Zoe's Tale is a retelling of The Last Colony without it being a retelling of The Last Colony. As John Scalzi puts it:
"Writing a parallel time novel does not, in fact, just lazily retell the story in a previous book is hard"I guess Scalzi got a lot of heat after The Last Colony and left some unanswered questions about werewolves and what Zoe did when she was off-world and what she brought back with her when she came back to Roanoke. To me Scalzi excellently wrote a book through a teenager's eyes about being uprooted from her home, starting a new colony, and seeing her family and friends being put through many dangers. Since this is a YA book it also has her go through her first love and heartache.
As I mentioned in an earlier post, Scalzi really did the parallel story and even changed the genre of the book. Kinda, sorta in a way.
I'll rate this 4.5 stars and a solid 8 on my grading. Great book in the middle of an average series.
Zoe's Tale by John Scalzi (2008)
Book 4 in the Old Man's War series
No comments:
Post a Comment